Tutor: Thanks, Mike, for dropping by. I've read the proposal for your project, which is an oral history of the local football team, particularly the time around 1983 when they won the league championship. But first, how do you define oral history?
Mike: Well, in fact, I used the definition you gave us last year in our research methodology class. I found the handout in my file. The definition says that oral histories are interviews or conversations about some aspect of the past, which is considered historically or socially important. The interviews are with people who took part in whatever it’s about. So they’ll be a record that historians can use later for all those academic articles they write. And although history textbooks are mostly about famous people and important events, oral history can be about ordinary people doing ordinary things. Oral history really seems to have started in the States.
Tutor: You’re right. In fact, the first modern oral history interviews were done by a historian in New York. By that time, audio technology had improved so much that it was fairly easy to record those interviews.
Mike: I was also interested in how the internet has contributed to oral history studies.
Tutor: Yes, it means that lots of people can access the material, and that’s great. Also, the interactive nature of the better websites means that more students get interested in oral history.
Mike: But from what I’ve read, the real contribution of the internet is that the recording of the interviews will be preserved forever. In the old days, the tapes would just wear out, and after some years, you couldn’t really use them, but not now.
Tutor: You’re right, of course. Anyhow, let’s move on to the subject of your project. Why did you decide to study a sports team?
Mike: Well, actually, I don’t even like football very much, and some of my friends think I’m crazy to go for that subject. But my dad is a huge fan, and he might be able to help me.
Tutor: Hmm. And how did you find out the background about the team? You talked to the team manager, I assume?
Mike: Yes, I did manage to track him down, and I looked at all the old news stories about the team in the town newspaper office. That was where I got the most helpful information. I had high hopes that the local library would have lots of stuff, but they don’t keep any records for more than 10 years.
Tutor: I know that you managed to locate 8 out of 10 of the original 18 members of the team using an old-fashioned method, didn’t you? Not a website or anything, just the telephone directory?
Mike: Yes, I didn’t even need to use the local team’s records.
Tutor: Okay, now, I’ve read your proposal carefully. Overall, your plan seems excellent, but I want to discuss how you might improve it.
Mike: Great.
Tutor: I’ve read through the list of questions you’ve drafted. I felt most of them are rather complex to be processed as oral questions. You don’t have too many, which is good, but you should try to do something about that problem.
Mike: Right, I’ll work on them.
Tutor: And the time you’ve allotted for each interview? Actually, I think you may have scheduled too much time for each. You want them to be tight, not going on and on. That makes for better results.
Mike: I can change the schedule.
Tutor: One thing I’m nervous about is the recording equipment. I’ve got an old recorder. It runs without making too much noise, and it isn’t complicated, but it sometimes just doesn’t seem to work. It stopped during an interview I tried out with my dad.
Tutor: All the important thing is just to be ready. If anything happens, take some spare batteries, spares, or even an extra recorder.
Tutor: Now, I’m a little concerned with the subjects you’ve chosen to cover. The topics seem quite general, not very specific. For example, "Why did they like playing for this team?" You need to talk about more exact things and feelings. That way, your results will be more valuable.
Mike: I’ll try to refine them.
Tutor: And, you know, the plan for my report seems to be just to report back more or less what the players say—what happened when, what they each did, and so on. But I’m not sure about that.
Tutor: Yes, although your outline seems long enough, change it to indicate that you plan to include your own evaluation of the data you get from your interviewees. Anyhow, best of luck on your project. I look forward to seeing the results.
Mike: Thanks for your help.